Top five lists

Each week we each rank a top five without comparing notes first.

Episode 9 · November 6, 2026

Top 5 Screenplays of All Time

Each brother's #1 was the other's #4, Good Will Hunting and The Social Network.

Episode 8 · October 31, 2026

Top 5 Male Actors of the 2020s

We each picked the male actors defining this decade in film, and only one name made both lists.

Episode 7 · October 23, 2026

Top 5 Romantic Comedies

Only one movie made both of our lists, and it's not in the same spot.

Episode 6 · October 15, 2026

Top 5 Christopher Nolan Movies

Thirteen films to choose from, and our top three lined up exactly, in the same order.

Episode 5 · October 9, 2026

Top 5 Sports Films

Decades of sports movies to choose from, and Moneyball landed at #4 for both of us again.

Episode 4 · October 1, 2026

Top 5 Tom Cruise Movies

Decades of Tom Cruise to pick from, and we only matched on one film in the same spot.

Episode 3 · September 24, 2026

Top 5 Steven Spielberg Films

Directed by Spielberg only, so no Poltergeist. We agreed on the top two, just not the order.

Episode 2 · September 18, 2026

Top 5 Pixar Movies

Thirty-one Pixar films to choose from, and we only agreed on one.

Episode 1 · September 10, 2026

Top 5 Best Picture Winners

Every Best Picture winner since the 1920s was eligible. It was much harder than we expected.