On episode 8, Jeff reviewed You Can See Everything solo since Matt hadn't had a chance to see it yet. He's been following the Elizabeth Holmes story since reading Bad Blood, so a documentary built around the interviews she and her partner Billy Evans gave to Nathan Fielder before she reported to prison was already a must-watch.
Jeff didn't go in alone in spirit, at least. He pointed out that the film had the strongest opening weekend for a documentary since Fahrenheit 9/11, pulling in about $15 million in only 855 theaters, enough to outgross Wildwood at the box office that same weekend.
A lot of that comes down to Fielder, whose name Matt admitted he didn't even recognize going in. Jeff chalked that up to Matt skipping HBO growing up, and said Fielder's style bleeds straight into the documentary: witty, probing questions that visibly get under the skin of his subjects, especially Billy Evans. He called Fielder "almost like a comedic, investigative journalist," and was careful to draw a line around what kind of film this actually is. It's not a comedy, he said, even though you'll catch yourself laughing the same way you might at a Nathan For You clip, out of cringe and absurdity rather than an actual joke. Underneath that is a real exploration: is Holmes being genuine or manipulative, is Fielder the one getting played, and how closely does Billy Evans's controlling streak echo Sonny Balwani's, the Theranos co-founder who went to prison alongside her.
Jeff also flagged the film's two-part structure without spoiling the turn. He said the second half, which most people talking about the documentary have avoided discussing, recontextualizes a lot of what came before it, and that it was the stronger half for him.
On the Oscar conversation, Jeff was clear-eyed: a lock for Best Documentary in his view, with real Best Picture buzz circulating, though he wouldn't personally rank it as the best film of the year. He did say it's probably in his top five of everything he's seen in 2026.
The verdict was still a full five out of five, which Jeff called a "solid piece of filmmaking" and "a wild ride" that's been going since Bad Blood first broke the story, with the possibility of more to come. Content-wise, he flagged a fair amount of profanity and one scene of nudity he said caught the entire theater off guard, enough that he saved the specifics for an offline conversation rather than spoiling it here.
Matt hasn't seen it yet, so there's no second score on the board for this one. But between the reviews he's read and the way Jeff described it, he's sold on checking it out himself.