For episode 10 we each put together a top five of our favorite superhero movies. See the full countdown. Jeff admits up front he's not really a superhero guy anymore, somewhere around the "Iron Man Three" era he just drifted off, but he still had a list ready to go. Matt cast a wider net, going all the way back to 1990. Between the two lists of five, exactly one movie showed up twice, and we didn't even agree on how good it was.
The one overlap
Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse made both lists, just not in the same neighborhood. For Jeff it landed at #5: "I really like these Into the Spider-Verse, Across the Spider-Verse movies. I think they're really fun and animated really well." For Matt it was #2, and a much bigger deal: "Exceptional animation... amazing action, so visually creative and ambitious, love it end to end. Except for the cliffhanger at the end — my goodness, people, my goodness. What were we doing?"
Two different Batmans
We both found room for a Batman movie, just not the same one. Jeff went with Batman Begins at #1, sticking with Christopher Nolan's take: "I feel like Christian Bale did all three. I think he grew into the role, I guess you could say." Matt wasn't as sure about that growth, joking back, "If he grew into that role, I'd say he digressed in the third."
Matt's own Batman pick was The Batman at #4, the 2022 Matt Reeves version: "The Batman was just so unique and different from the other Batman films... so dark, so unbelievably dark. But I was enthralled with the whole thing," especially next to the Nolan trilogy he also loves.
The rest of the lists
Matt opened his list with Unbreakable at #5, M. Night Shyamalan's original take just after The Sixth Sense: "The slow-burn development of someone realizing he's a superhero is interesting. It's not action-packed. It's restrained. It's a very original story." At #3 he went all the way back to the 1990 live-action Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, which he watched constantly as a kid: "I love the Shredder in that one. I love the dialogue... there's so much great martial arts... I still think it's great." His #1 was Captain America: The Winter Soldier: "The political thriller aspect of it, and the action, they elevated it for Winter Soldier. The action is leaps and bounds more exciting, more compelling, really in your face. And it wasn't all CGI."
Jeff's other three picks were Thor: Ragnarok at #4, which he still calls "pretty fun," with Matt agreeing it's "probably the most enjoyable in terms of just hilarious Marvel film that's out there"; the original Guardians of the Galaxy at #3, which he likes because "you don't have to take it too seriously, you don't have to know all the different plot points, you can just jump into it"; and The Rocketeer at #2, a childhood favorite mostly for its James Horner score, which Matt still remembers blasting on repeat on a road trip until the rest of the car made him stop.
Honorable mentions went to Jeff's Captain Marvel, which he said held up better than he remembered, and Matt's X2: X-Men United, mostly for the Wolverine material.
Hear the full breakdown, along with our reviews of What's Up, Doc? and Being Heumann, on episode 10.