FilmwardSubscribe
← All posts

November 11, 2026

Obsession: same score, opposite verdict on Bear

Curry Barker's $750,000 indie horror hit earned a four out of five from both of us, but we split on whether Bear is a victim of the love spell or a guy who had every chance to leave.

For episode 9 we picked up Obsession, the indie horror film built around a one-wish willow tree that traps a young woman named Nikki in a love spell. We landed on the exact same score, a four out of five, and then spent most of the conversation disagreeing about the guy at the center of it.

Matt was drawn in by the production story as much as the film itself. Curry Barker made this on a $750,000 budget, editing it himself in his bedroom with nobody on set calling the shots, and the cast is essentially five people plus a small Andy Richter cameo. Matt thought Inde Navarrette's performance as Nikki was the standout, "all over the place" in the best way as she snowballs in intensity scene to scene, while Michael Johnston's Bear stays checked-out and passive by comparison. The slow-burn pacing, long scenes building tension before something goes sideways, is closer to his speed than jump-scare horror, and he compared the rhythm to Tarantino. He also watched it filtered through VidAngel with one of his sons, stripping out roughly 127 F-words, and said the story still held together with the filter on.

Jeff came at it more from the business angle: a $750,000 budget that turned into roughly $400 million worldwide for Focus Features, powered by a 30% jump in its second weekend. He's mostly avoided horror since being scared off the genre as a teenager by The Sixth Sense and The Ring, but found this one, like Backrooms, unrealistic enough and light enough on jump scares that he could actually enjoy it.

Where we split was on Bear. Matt sees him more as a victim of the willow's spell. Jeff lands on "willing participant," pointing out Bear had plenty of chances to walk away from the situation, even though the movie shows that leaving town doesn't actually work, and chose not to. Jeff also gives Bear a partial pass as a product of his generation's awkwardness about just saying you're interested in someone without some big, dramatic declaration.

Same score, same willow, two different readings of the guy stuck inside it. See the full review, or catch the discussion starting at 9:15 in episode 9.

Films in this post