FilmwardSubscribe
← All posts

November 20, 2026

Being Heumann: should this have been a documentary instead?

Matt and Jeff agreed Being Heumann tells an important, little-known civil rights story, then spent most of the segment arguing over whether the docudrama treatment was the right call.

For episode 10 we picked up Being Heumann, Sian Heder's follow-up to Coda about Judy Heumann and the 1977 occupation of a federal building in San Francisco, the 25-day sit-in that finally forced the government to issue regulations for Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act. Matt gave it a 3.5, Jeff a 3, and the real disagreement wasn't about the history. It was about the format.

Matt laid out the case against docudrama up front: "I almost always prefer an actual documentary over a docudrama just because I feel like the docudramas always tend to create more drama than maybe there actually was, or create characters to move the plot forward that in reality weren't there." He gave the film credit for restraint, noting it "did not present her as flawless, as some perfect leader," and pointed to a scene where a blind protester pushes back on tearing out curbs for wheelchairs as proof the movement's own internal arguments made it in. But the ending lost him: "at the end they talk about Judy and Califano having a phone conversation, and it's like that didn't actually happen. Things like that always kinda bother me, where I just want to know the truth."

Jeff came at it from the other side. He'd never seen Crip Camp, the 2020 Oscar-nominated documentary covering similar ground, and thought the dramatized version earns its keep by reaching people documentaries don't: "it's bringing awareness of this story to a different audience that maybe isn't as into documentaries as others are." He also pointed to the casting as a strength carried over from Coda: "she didn't take a bunch of non-disabled people and say, okay, you're gonna be playing a disabled person in this movie. Instead, she cast people who are actually disabled."

Both brothers landed on the same complaint regardless of format: length. Jeff thought the 127-minute runtime could have been closer to 100. Matt agreed it ran "unnecessarily long at times," and said the language is heavy enough, almost to the point of distraction, that it's worth knowing there's a filtered version available on VidAngel.

Where they ended up agreeing was on the history itself. Neither brother knew much about Section 504 going in, and both came away struck by how recent the fight for things like building ramps and accessible restrooms actually is. Matt put it simply: "there's a real struggle, real history that goes along with this that changed how the United States is set up." That's the part that survives the format argument: whether you'd rather have watched Crip Camp or Being Heumann, the story underneath it is one they both think is worth knowing.

See the full review, or catch the discussion starting at 38:21 in episode 10.

Films in this post